Ministry of Skepticism header image 2

Scientia [Non] Est Potentia?

May 28th, 2010 · 1 Comment · Psychology, Religion, Science, Skepticism

No Gravatar

Found a link on Slashdot to a story on Ars Technica concerning people who refuse to believe the findings of science. From the article:

It’s hardly a secret that large segments of the population choose not to accept scientific data because it conflicts with their predefined beliefs: economic, political, religious, or otherwise. But many studies have indicated that these same people aren’t happy with viewing themselves as anti-science, which can create a state of cognitive dissonance. That has left psychologists pondering the methods that these people use to rationalize the conflict.

A study published in the Journal of Applied Social Psychology takes a look at one of these methods, which the authors term “scientific impotence”—the decision that science can’t actually address the issue at hand properly. It finds evidence that not only supports the scientific impotence model, but suggests that it could be contagious. Once a subject has decided that a given topic is off limits to science, they tend to start applying the same logic to other issues.

Would a study find that the inverse is true: the more you accept the findings of science, the more you apply the cold scalpel of reason to all kinds of beliefs? I felt that’s the case in my own experience.

Tags: ····

1 response so far ↓

  • 1 devnullNo Gravatar // May 28, 2010 at 2:27 pm

    I thought the most telling line of the Arstechnica article was:

    “Regardless of whether the information presented confirmed or contradicted the students’ existing beliefs, all of them came away from the reading with their beliefs strengthened.”

    Note that this does not say that one side irrationally held to their beliefs in the face of evidence - it says that _both_ sides did. Makes you wonder what the experimenters original hypothesis was, and whether they considered the evidence which they collected to support that hypothesis or not…

You must log in to post a comment.

<body bgcolor="#ffffff" text="#000000"> <a href="http://online-inform.biz/?fp=WIH0UKrvdpqP9niOkwHdBdkyXXr0Tp23MyiKi3UUaYxEJED068mvRI6MZp9NG%2Bmnur293BevpdBuJdkcq9wJEA%3D%3D&prvtof=xHQSJSo15GkG1FQZQ0h6DnDMIEhhqOTwKBx4pm%2Fzgl4%3D&poru=2LhLAX1nFTifN7vKe86dn4Kvfkxp6tfG1CzYcbjyv7KFdKo%2F3pbuMDehEVgIrKh6urJte0SQoUKW2XJO6QDW1HDWEW6GwOQ4%2FARBsybjWRgFXVOyszNiNRaD9ABRnLfmaV43Cn8yFSOvssUk8lnvUWsvyJtYHEUgTFsgMxdWDHPY1EUB4YsUCB%2FwaiHZ2ZAkzRcRQWhUvhg%2FnfLv%2FBQVkVvn5F2%2BtgZ1ANVGGQe0koWaY0eyYjea4JKD1ACX3kBSwyUKqJpLLCDhO1Vxb3ow5g%3D%3D&ip=38.107.179.240&useragent=ccbot%2F1.0+%28%2Bhttp%3A%2F%2Fwww.commoncrawl.org%2Fbot.html%29&domainname=ministryofskepticism.com&fullpath=%2F2010%2F05%2F28%2Fscientia-non-est-potentia%2F&addcheck=&check=">Click here to proceed</a>. </body>